SPOTTER.
You have to decide based on everything. Here's everything — graded.
Game View
CAR 20 · NO 17
FINAL→
CARCAR

Carolina Panthers @ New Orleans Saints

NONO
Sun 11/15 · 12:00 PM CST · final grade · injuries: 13 out · 5 on IR · 2 questionable
SPREAD · Panthers +1
no lean
MARKET+1-115MODEL+1-125
cover 55% · market 52%
ML · Panthers
no lean
MARKET-106MODEL-102
win 50% · market 50%
TOTAL · under 48.5
no lean
MARKET48.5+101MODEL51.2points
under 54% · market 48%
the letter is how far we sit from the market, not how sure we are

THE QUARTERBACKS

CARCARCarolina Panthers · Bryce Young — started
Rates +0.01 expected points a dropback (16th of the 28 starters this week), over his last 825 dropbacks.
This season: 186 of 306, 2,197 yards, 16 TD, 6 INT in 8 games.
NONONew Orleans Saints · Tyler Shough — started
Rates +0.02 expected points a dropback (14th of the 28 starters this week), over his last 718 dropbacks.
This season: 204 of 307, 1,986 yards, 14 TD, 6 INT in 8 games.
On rating the two are level (within 0.03 a dropback).
What it means for the grade: nothing yet. No letter reads this rating. Tested on 2021-25, it made the all-factors model better but no better than today's letter for betting, and the moneyline market weighs a quarterback about as far as past results justify.

SPREAD · Panthers +1

SPREAD: Graded, no lean — the number is where we'd put it.
THE PICTURE — what the number already weighssized against each other · measured against the line — a stat the market already prices can point opposite its usual read
Indoors on turf.54%
Power ratings give the Saints a 54% win chance here.26%
The Panthers keep drives on schedule on 42% of snaps.12%
Division rematch — these staffs have years of tape on each other.8%
Market: Panthers +1 at -115 (pinnacle, quoted 11:25 AM CST) · the full picture prices it -125 · divergence 3 points — band none.

MONEYLINE · Panthers

ML: Graded, no lean — the number is where we'd put it.
THE PICTURE — what the number already weighs
Division rematch — these staffs have years of tape on each other.52%
Indoors.35%
The Saints keep drives on schedule on 42% of snaps.7%
Power ratings give the Saints a 54% win chance here.6%
Market: Panthers at -106 (pinnacle, quoted 11:25 AM CST) · the full picture prices it -102 · divergence 0 points — band none.

TOTAL · under 48.5

TOTAL: Graded, no lean — the number is where we'd put it.
The closing total on NFL games predicts the outcome about as well as a coin flip — nobody reliably out-guesses it, and we won't pretend to. Here's what the number already weighs.
THE PICTURE — what the number already weighs
Indoors on turf.63%
Division rematch — these staffs have years of tape on each other.35%
The Saints are scoring 23.6 points a game over their last 10 and allowing 26.1.2%
Market: under 48.5 at +101 (pinnacle, quoted 11:25 AM CST) · the full picture prices it -119 · model expects ~51.2 points · divergence 6 points — band none.

INJURY REPORT

the wire as of 3:20 PM CST · polled every five minutes inside the last ninety before kickoff · shown whether or not the number weighs it — the closing line already carries the report, so the model reads none of this (audition 2026-09-01)
CARCARCarolina Panthers · 7 out · 4 on IR
Haynes King QB out coach's decision out: played 0% of the time (n 131) Sun 11/15 11:26 AM CST
AJ Dillon RB out coach's decision out: played 0% of the time (n 289) Sun 11/15 10:38 AM CST
Bobby Okereke LB out foot out · did not practice: played 0% of the time (n 477) Sun 11/15 10:38 AM CST
Ja'Tavion Sanders TE out coach's decision out: played 0% of the time (n 260) Sun 11/15 11:17 AM CST
Sam Hecht C out coach's decision out: played 0% of the time (n 687) Sun 11/15 10:38 AM CST
TeRah Edwards DT out coach's decision out: played 0% of the time (n 523) Sun 11/15 10:38 AM CST
Will Lee III CB out hamstring out · limited practice: played 0% of the time (n 76) Sun 11/15 11:23 AM CST
4 on injured reserve — season-long, already in the line · show
Brady Christensen G injured reserve hamstring will not play Sat 11/14 1:38 PM CST
Jaycee Horn CB injured reserve quadriceps (strain) will not play Mon 11/9 5:18 PM CST
Jonathon Brooks RB injured reserve groin (surgery) will not play Sat 11/14 1:01 PM CST
Mike Jackson CB injured reserve groin (surgery) will not play Sat 11/14 1:23 PM CST
NONONew Orleans Saints · 6 out · 1 on IR · 2 questionable
Zach Wilson QB out coach's decision out: played 0% of the time (n 131) Sun 11/15 11:21 AM CST
CJ Donaldson RB out shoulder out · did not practice: played 0% of the time (n 270) Sun 11/15 10:34 AM CST
Erik McCoy C out biceps out · did not practice: played 0% of the time (n 621) Sun 11/15 10:34 AM CST
Jaylan Ford LB out coach's decision out: played 0% of the time (n 527) Sun 11/15 10:34 AM CST
Mike Reid CB out coach's decision out: played 0% of the time (n 982) Sun 11/15 10:34 AM CST
Taliese Fuaga OT out knee (sprain) out · did not practice: played 0% of the time (n 621) Sun 11/15 10:34 AM CST
Asim Richards OT questionable knee questionable · full practice: played 73% of the time (n 183) Sun 11/15 2:50 PM CST
Pete Werner LB questionable hamstring questionable: played 70% of the time (n 784) Sun 11/15 1:46 PM CST
1 on injured reserve — season-long, already in the line · show
Christen Miller DT injured reserve knee will not play Sat 11/14 7:04 PM CST

PLAYER PROPS

projected from play-by-play — team volume x player share x efficiency, every piece shrunk; receivers' yards and catches from the receiver read, a model of their targets, air yards and who is throwing — against the latest captured line · the model's % is corrected against a replay of every 2025 game · a lean needs 8 points of leftover after the vig-free price, except a tight end's touchdown, which the touchdown read prices and leans on whenever its chance beats the raw price · FAIR is the chance once the model gets only the say it has earned against the book this season, market by market (none on backs' carries and rushing yards, QB passing yards and attempts or touchdowns; a tenth to a sixth on the rest; on the receiver read about a quarter on yards and two-fifths on catches) — the return per $1 is priced on it, so a lean can show a loss · leans rank by how often leans of their kind (market and side) have hit this season, then by the model's return, receivers' yards and catches half on their own FAIR chance and half on their return · STRONGEST marks the top firm ones: a big sample behind the share, several books on the line, and no sign the book is pricing a role we have not seen · the lane's own record: 1778-1923 on 3701 settled leans, -0.4% at the price · every priced projection: model said over 42%, over hit 42% (n 7,638)
built 11:05 AM CST · lines as of 11:00 AM CST
John Metchie III WR receptions projects 2.2 line 1.5 over 62% vs book 36% · fair 49% lean over +165 bovada +29% per $1 strongest receiver read: 10% of the targets and 10% of the air yards over his last 6 games, 6.6 yards downfield, 7.1 yds/att throwing tonight against 6.5 in his window (shrunk, 68 tgt) 68 targets behind the share, 5 books on the line, 26 points of leftover after the 2025 correction, fair chance 49%, +29% per $1 at the price
Tetairoa McMillan WR receptions projects 4.7 line 5.5 over 29% vs book 43% · fair 38% lean under -147 draftkings +4% per $1 strongest receiver read: 24% of the targets and 31% of the air yards over his last 6 games, 11.6 yards downfield (shrunk, 124 tgt) 124 targets behind the share, 6 books on the line, 14 points of leftover after the 2025 correction, fair chance 62%, +4% per $1 at the price
Travis Etienne RB rushing yards projects 12 line 29.5 over 18% vs book 50% · fair 50% lean under -110 betmgm -4% per $1 strongest CAR run D +21 yds/g vs league: carries x1.009, yds/carry x1.009; 3.2 carries x 4.06 yds/carry (shrunk, 223 carries), x0.98 for who is throwing (7.1 yds/att tonight, 7.9 in his window) 223 carries behind the share, rushing yards unders have hit 58% of 257 so far (running backs 56% of 178), 4 books on the line, 32 points of leftover after the 2025 correction, fair chance 50%, -4% per $1 at the price
John Metchie III WR receiving yards projects 26 line 7.5 over 78% vs book 50% · fair 58% lean over -108 betonlineag +12% per $1 receiver read: 10% of the targets and 10% of the air yards over his last 6 games, 6.6 yards downfield, 7.1 yds/att throwing tonight against 6.5 in his window (shrunk, 68 tgt) same read as the receptions lean above — one bet, not two
Jalen Coker WR receptions projects 4.0 line 4.5 over 32% vs book 48% · fair 43% lean under -120 betmgm +5% per $1 receiver read: 19% of the targets and 23% of the air yards over his last 6 games, 10.4 yards downfield (shrunk, 86 tgt) (off his last 6 available games: of the last 6 games he was out of 1, left 1 early)
Noah Fant TE receptions projects 1.9 line 1.5 over 50% vs book 35% · fair 43% lean over +175 betmgm +18% per $1 receiver read: 8% of the targets and 5% of the air yards over his last 6 games, 3.9 yards downfield, CAR allows -1.0 yds/target to tight ends against the league (shrunk, 45 tgt) (off his last 6 available games: of the last 6 games he was out of 1, left 0 early) thin sample behind the share (45 tgt)
Devaughn Vele WR receiving yards projects 46 line 29.5 over 69% vs book 50% · fair 55% lean over -109 draftkings +6% per $1 receiver read: 17% of the targets and 23% of the air yards over his last 6 games, 10.5 yards downfield (shrunk, 89 tgt)
Travis Etienne RB carries projects 3.1 line 8.5 over 9% vs book 52% · fair 52% lean under +100 bovada -4% per $1 CAR run D +21 yds/g vs league: carries x1.009, yds/carry x1.009; 25.4 team carries x 13% share (off his last 6 available games: of the last 6 games he was out of 0, left 1 early) same read as the rushing yards lean above — one bet, not two
Tyler Shough QB carries projects 4.0 line 4.5 over 43% vs book 54% · fair 53% lean under +105 bovada -4% per $1 CAR run D +21 yds/g vs league: carries x1.009, yds/carry x1.009; 25.4 team carries x 17% share off his last 8 full starts, shrunk to a starter's 15%
Jordyn Tyson WR receptions projects 1.6 line 4.5 over 6% vs book 41% · fair 35% lean under -161 fanduel +6% per $1 CAR run D +21 yds/g vs league: carries x1.009, yds/carry x1.009; 2.5 targets x 67% catch rate (shrunk, 5 tgt) (off his last 5 available games: of the last 6 games he was out of 4, left 1 early) thin sample behind the share (5 tgt)
47 more priced projections with less leftover
13 projections without a posted line (Alvin Kamara, Anthony Tyus III, Audric Estime, Barion Brown, Bryce Lance, Brycen Tremayne, Mitchell Evans, Trevor Etienne)

ANYTIME TD

from the day's BEST ANYTIME TD on the sheet: the model's touchdown leans ranked by its chance the player scores — the top five on a day of two or more games, the one best on a one-game day. A lean means the model's chance beats the price's by 8 points or more, not that it expects a touchdown. They stay out of the list above and off STRONGEST, and the return per $1 uses the book's own chance, since the model has not earned a say on touchdowns · this list: 14-56 on 70 picks, -28.6% at the price (luck alone swings that ±17%) · the model said 36%, they scored 20% · every touchdown lean: 45-236 on 281 touchdown leans, +27.2% at the price (luck alone swings that ±21%) · the model said 27%, they scored 16% · tight ends from the touchdown read's group under it: its chance beats the price, its five likeliest by its fair chance, the return per $1 on that fair chance; tested once on 2026's prices it went 22-111, +17% at the typical book, long prices · that group: 1-11 on 12 picks, -54.2% at the price (luck alone swings that ±46%) · the model said 22%, they scored 8% · every touchdown-read lean: 3-25 on 28 touchdown leans, -14.3% at the price (luck alone swings that ±49%) · the model said 18%, they scored 11%
Alvin Kamara RB anytime TD projects 0.47 expected TDs scores 33% vs book 23% · fair 23% lean yes +330 bovada -0% per $1 CAR run D +21 yds/g vs league: carries x1.009, yds/carry x1.009; 2.88 team TDs x 16% share (TD share 19%, red-zone touch share 14%) no. 4 of the day's best anytime TD
Darren Waller TE anytime TD projects 0.31 expected TDs scores 27% vs book 22% · fair 25% lean yes +360 fanatics +17% per $1 touchdown read: 14% of the red-zone targets and 14% of all targets over his last 6 games, 14% of his targets scored, NO lets 0.25 more tight ends a game score than the league does (shrunk, 69 tgt) no. 1 of the day's tight ends on the touchdown read
Tommy Tremble TE anytime TD projects 0.19 expected TDs scores 18% vs book 17% · fair 17% lean yes +500 betmgm +4% per $1 touchdown read: 19% of the red-zone targets and 11% of all targets over his last 6 games, 9% of his targets scored, NO lets 0.25 more tight ends a game score than the league does (shrunk, 46 tgt) no. 5 of the day's tight ends on the touchdown read · thin sample behind the share (46 tgt)
SITUATIONAL CONDITIONSdetected for this game · not a grade input — anything that carries weight appears in THE PICTURE
none detected for this game
Honest row: grades cap at the band — extreme disagreement is as often our error as the market's. Totals carry no lean this season by ruling, not by this game's number. Graded against the line at grade time; the model was validated against closing lines. Weather from forecast; regrade if conditions flip. Injury wire as of 3:20 PM CST; a game-time decision can flip after the last poll.
Raw grade details (all passes)
[
 {
  "market": "ml",
  "pass_kind": "first",
  "graded_utc": "2026-11-14T16:45:39Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 116,
  "feature_version": 2,
  "model_p": 0.5508644341856362,
  "p_shipped": 0.5508644341856362,
  "model_mu": null,
  "market_p": 0.5558375634517766,
  "divergence": -0.0049731292661403526,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 0.0,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-11-14T16:00:39Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": "forecast",
  "result": "won",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "style",
    "phrase": "Division rematch \u2014 these staffs have years of tape on each other.",
    "share": 0.519,
    "contribution": 0.16609,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_go4_szn",
     "a_go4_szn",
     "div_game"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "env",
    "phrase": "Indoors.",
    "share": 0.3498,
    "contribution": -0.11193,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "alt_kft",
     "season_idx",
     "roof_closed"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "epa",
    "phrase": "The Saints keep drives on schedule on 42% of snaps.",
    "share": 0.0744,
    "contribution": -0.02382,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_off_success10",
     "a_off_success10",
     "h_off_rush_epa10"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "Power ratings give the Saints a 54% win chance here.",
    "share": 0.0569,
    "contribution": -0.0182,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "a_elo",
     "h_elo",
     "h_pa10"
    ]
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "ml",
  "pass_kind": "final",
  "graded_utc": "2026-11-15T17:30:39Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 116,
  "feature_version": 2,
  "model_p": 0.4959929212947526,
  "p_shipped": 0.4959929212947526,
  "model_mu": null,
  "market_p": 0.4974358974358974,
  "divergence": -0.0014429761411448028,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 0.0,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-11-15T17:25:39Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": "forecast",
  "result": "won",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "style",
    "phrase": "Division rematch \u2014 these staffs have years of tape on each other.",
    "share": 0.519,
    "contribution": 0.16609,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_go4_szn",
     "a_go4_szn",
     "div_game"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "env",
    "phrase": "Indoors.",
    "share": 0.3498,
    "contribution": -0.11193,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "alt_kft",
     "season_idx",
     "roof_closed"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "epa",
    "phrase": "The Saints keep drives on schedule on 42% of snaps.",
    "share": 0.0744,
    "contribution": -0.02382,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_off_success10",
     "a_off_success10",
     "h_off_rush_epa10"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "Power ratings give the Saints a 54% win chance here.",
    "share": 0.0569,
    "contribution": -0.0182,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "a_elo",
     "h_elo",
     "h_pa10"
    ]
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "spread",
  "pass_kind": "first",
  "graded_utc": "2026-11-14T16:45:39Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 113,
  "feature_version": 2,
  "model_p": 0.4656495576875235,
  "p_shipped": 0.4656495576875235,
  "model_mu": null,
  "market_p": 0.4961439588688946,
  "divergence": -0.030494401181371145,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": -2.5,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-11-14T16:00:39Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": "forecast",
  "result": "won",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "env",
    "phrase": "Indoors on turf.",
    "share": 0.541,
    "contribution": -0.05382,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "turf",
     "roof_closed",
     "season_idx"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "Power ratings give the Saints a 54% win chance here.",
    "share": 0.2552,
    "contribution": 0.02539,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_elo",
     "h_pa10",
     "a_elo"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "epa",
    "phrase": "The Panthers keep drives on schedule on 42% of snaps.",
    "share": 0.1199,
    "contribution": -0.01193,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "a_off_success10",
     "h_off_success10",
     "a_off_rush_epa10"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "style",
    "phrase": "Division rematch \u2014 these staffs have years of tape on each other.",
    "share": 0.0839,
    "contribution": 0.00835,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_go4_szn",
     "div_game",
     "a_go4_szn"
    ]
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "spread",
  "pass_kind": "final",
  "graded_utc": "2026-11-15T17:30:39Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 113,
  "feature_version": 2,
  "model_p": 0.44515632234227726,
  "p_shipped": 0.44515632234227726,
  "model_mu": null,
  "market_p": 0.4782608695652174,
  "divergence": -0.03310454722294015,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": -1.0,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-11-15T17:25:39Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": "forecast",
  "result": "won",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "env",
    "phrase": "Indoors on turf.",
    "share": 0.541,
    "contribution": -0.05382,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "turf",
     "roof_closed",
     "season_idx"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "Power ratings give the Saints a 54% win chance here.",
    "share": 0.2552,
    "contribution": 0.02539,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_elo",
     "h_pa10",
     "a_elo"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "epa",
    "phrase": "The Panthers keep drives on schedule on 42% of snaps.",
    "share": 0.1199,
    "contribution": -0.01193,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "a_off_success10",
     "h_off_success10",
     "a_off_rush_epa10"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "style",
    "phrase": "Division rematch \u2014 these staffs have years of tape on each other.",
    "share": 0.0839,
    "contribution": 0.00835,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_go4_szn",
     "div_game",
     "a_go4_szn"
    ]
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "total",
  "pass_kind": "first",
  "graded_utc": "2026-11-14T16:45:39Z",
  "rung": "l2",
  "fit_id": 48,
  "feature_version": 1,
  "model_p": 0.45591621053098785,
  "p_shipped": 0.45591621053098785,
  "model_mu": 51.230201180826924,
  "market_p": 0.5116883116883117,
  "divergence": -0.055772101157323895,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 48.5,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-11-14T16:00:39Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": "forecast",
  "result": "won",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "env",
    "phrase": "Indoors on turf.",
    "share": 0.6308,
    "contribution": 0.19441,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "season_idx",
     "roof_closed",
     "wind_out"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "style",
    "phrase": "Division rematch \u2014 these staffs have years of tape on each other.",
    "share": 0.3535,
    "contribution": 0.10895,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_go4_szn",
     "a_go4_szn",
     "div_game"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "The Saints are scoring 23.6 points a game over their last 10 and allowing 26.1.",
    "share": 0.0158,
    "contribution": -0.00486,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_elo",
     "h_pa10",
     "a_pa10"
    ]
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "total",
  "pass_kind": "final",
  "graded_utc": "2026-11-15T17:30:39Z",
  "rung": "l2",
  "fit_id": 48,
  "feature_version": 1,
  "model_p": 0.45591621053098785,
  "p_shipped": 0.45591621053098785,
  "model_mu": 51.230201180826924,
  "market_p": 0.5167095115681234,
  "divergence": -0.06079330103713554,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 48.5,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-11-15T17:25:39Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": "forecast",
  "result": "won",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "env",
    "phrase": "Indoors on turf.",
    "share": 0.6308,
    "contribution": 0.19441,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "season_idx",
     "roof_closed",
     "wind_out"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "style",
    "phrase": "Division rematch \u2014 these staffs have years of tape on each other.",
    "share": 0.3535,
    "contribution": 0.10895,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_go4_szn",
     "a_go4_szn",
     "div_game"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "The Saints are scoring 23.6 points a game over their last 10 and allowing 26.1.",
    "share": 0.0158,
    "contribution": -0.00486,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_elo",
     "h_pa10",
     "a_pa10"
    ]
   }
  ]
 }
]