SPOTTER.
You have to decide based on everything. Here's everything — graded.
Game View
DAL 1 · PIT 2
FINAL→
DALDAL

Dallas Stars @ Pittsburgh Penguins

PITPIT
Sat 10/10 · 6:00 PM CDT · final grade · goalies: both confirmed
PUCKLINE · Stars -1.5
B
MARKET-1.5+146MODEL-1.5+137
cover 42% · market 39%
ML · Stars
no lean
MARKET-182MODEL-181
win 64% · market 63%
TOTAL · over 6.5
no lean
MARKET6.5+102MODEL6.6goals
over 49% · market 48%
the letter is how far we sit from the market, not how sure we are

THE GOALIES

DALDALDallas Stars · J. Oettinger — started
Last 10 starts: allowed 2.2 goals per 60 minutes against 2.3 expected from the shots he faced — right about what the shots he faced predicted.
Track record since 2021-22 (recent games count most): 0.06 goals a game better than average.
This season: 2-1-0 · .967 save percentage · 3 starts in the last 14 days.
PITPITPittsburgh Penguins · A. Silovs — started
Last 10 starts: allowed 2.8 goals per 60 minutes against 2.6 expected from the shots he faced — 0.3 more than expected.
Track record since 2022-23 (recent games count most): 0.20 goals a game worse than average.
This season: 2-1-0 · .859 save percentage · 3 starts in the last 14 days.
On track record J. Oettinger rates about 0.26 goals a game better than A. Silovs.
What it means for the grade: over five seasons the closing price moved with goalie quality about as far as the results did, so this matchup is in the price these letters are graded against.

PUCK LINE · Stars -1.5

PUCKLINE: Lean: the Stars — a clear gap from the number, a step below our strongest. A read, not a proven edge.
Best price when graded: Stars -1.5 +150 at Matchbook (graded at +146, Pinnacle).
THE PICTURE — what's driving the 3-point gapsized against each other · measured against the line — a stat the market already prices can point opposite its usual read
The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.72%
The Penguins' starter has allowed about one extra goal every 3 starts, going by the chances he's faced over his last 30.22%
The Stars have scored about 2.3% more than their chances earned — shooting and goaltending that hot usually cools.6%
Market: Stars -1.5 at +146 (pinnacle, quoted 5:30 PM CDT) · the full picture prices it +137 · divergence 3 points — band B.

MONEYLINE · Stars

ML: Graded, no lean — the number is where we'd put it.
THE PICTURE — what the number already weighs
The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.54%
Power ratings make the Stars a 57% favorite here.33%
The Penguins' starter has allowed about one extra goal every 3 starts, going by the chances he's faced over his last 30.13%
Market: Stars at -182 (pinnacle, quoted 5:30 PM CDT) · the full picture prices it -181 · divergence 2 points — band none.

TOTAL · over 6.5

TOTAL: Graded, no lean — the number is where we'd put it.
The closing total on NHL games calls over/under about as well as a coin flip — four seasons say nobody out-guesses it, and we won't pretend to. We still grade it every game; here's what the number already weighs.
THE PICTURE — what the number already weighs
The Penguins have scored 4.2 goals a game over their last 25 and allowed 4.68%
The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.28%
The Penguins' starter has allowed about one extra goal every 3 starts, going by the chances he's faced over his last 30.4%
Market: over 6.5 at +102 (pinnacle, quoted 5:30 PM CDT) · the full picture prices it +105 · model expects ~6.6 goals · divergence 1 point — band none.
SITUATIONAL CONDITIONSdetected for this game · not a grade input — anything that carries weight appears in THE PICTURE
none detected for this game
Honest row: grades cap at the band — extreme disagreement is as often our error as the market's. Totals carry no lean this season by ruling, not by this game's number. Graded against the line at grade time; the model was validated against closing lines.
Raw grade details (all passes)
[
 {
  "market": "ml",
  "pass_kind": "first",
  "graded_utc": "2026-10-09T16:45:19Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 107,
  "feature_version": 1,
  "model_p": 0.422477266800446,
  "p_shipped": 0.422477266800446,
  "model_mu": null,
  "market_p": 0.43152454780361754,
  "divergence": -0.009047281003171537,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 0.0,
  "anchor_book": "williamhill",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-10-09T16:00:19Z",
  "lineup_known": 0,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": null,
  "result": "lost",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "situational",
    "phrase": "The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.",
    "share": 0.5705,
    "contribution": -0.44757,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_rest0",
     "h_g3in4",
     "h_miles7d_k"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "Power ratings make the Stars a 57% favorite here.",
    "share": 0.2805,
    "contribution": -0.22005,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "a_elo",
     "h_gf25",
     "a_xga25"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "No goaltending record for tonight's starter for the Stars \u2014 graded on league-typical assumptions.",
    "share": 0.149,
    "contribution": 0.11689,
    "kind": "gap",
    "features": [
     "a_gsax_miss",
     "h_gsax_miss",
     "a_goalie_b2b"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "Penguins: Starter not yet confirmed \u2014 this read assumes the likely netminder and updates at morning skate.",
    "share": 0.0,
    "contribution": 0.0,
    "kind": "missing",
    "features": []
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "Stars: Starter not yet confirmed \u2014 this read assumes the likely netminder and updates at morning skate.",
    "share": 0.0,
    "contribution": 0.0,
    "kind": "missing",
    "features": []
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "ml",
  "pass_kind": "final",
  "graded_utc": "2026-10-10T22:30:19Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 107,
  "feature_version": 1,
  "model_p": 0.35648157471778197,
  "p_shipped": 0.35648157471778197,
  "model_mu": null,
  "market_p": 0.37170263788968827,
  "divergence": -0.015221063171906302,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 0.0,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-10-10T22:30:19Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": null,
  "result": "lost",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "situational",
    "phrase": "The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.",
    "share": 0.537,
    "contribution": -0.44757,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_rest0",
     "h_g3in4",
     "h_miles7d_k"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "Power ratings make the Stars a 57% favorite here.",
    "share": 0.3347,
    "contribution": -0.27898,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "a_elo",
     "h_gf25",
     "a_xga25"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "The Penguins' starter has allowed about one extra goal every 3 starts, going by the chances he's faced over his last 30.",
    "share": 0.1282,
    "contribution": -0.10684,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_gsax30",
     "a_gsax30",
     "h_goalie_known"
    ]
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "puckline",
  "pass_kind": "first",
  "graded_utc": "2026-10-09T16:45:19Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 110,
  "feature_version": 1,
  "model_p": 0.59954165278139,
  "p_shipped": 0.59954165278139,
  "model_mu": null,
  "market_p": 0.6203473945409429,
  "divergence": -0.020805741759552854,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 1.5,
  "anchor_book": "williamhill",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-10-09T16:00:19Z",
  "lineup_known": 0,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": null,
  "result": "lost",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "situational",
    "phrase": "The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.",
    "share": 0.9688,
    "contribution": -0.37867,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_rest0",
     "h_g3in4",
     "h_miles7d_k"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "No goaltending record for tonight's starter for the Stars \u2014 graded on league-typical assumptions.",
    "share": 0.0312,
    "contribution": 0.01221,
    "kind": "gap",
    "features": [
     "a_gsax_miss",
     "h_gsax_miss",
     "a_goalie_b2b"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "Penguins: Starter not yet confirmed \u2014 this read assumes the likely netminder and updates at morning skate.",
    "share": 0.0,
    "contribution": 0.0,
    "kind": "missing",
    "features": []
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "Stars: Starter not yet confirmed \u2014 this read assumes the likely netminder and updates at morning skate.",
    "share": 0.0,
    "contribution": 0.0,
    "kind": "missing",
    "features": []
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "puckline",
  "pass_kind": "final",
  "graded_utc": "2026-10-10T22:30:19Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 110,
  "feature_version": 1,
  "model_p": 0.5788117432961006,
  "p_shipped": 0.5788117432961006,
  "model_mu": null,
  "market_p": 0.6059113300492611,
  "divergence": -0.027099586753160487,
  "band": "B",
  "anchor_line": 1.5,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-10-10T22:30:19Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": null,
  "result": "lost",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "situational",
    "phrase": "The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.",
    "share": 0.7194,
    "contribution": -0.37867,
    "kind": "driver",
    "features": [
     "h_rest0",
     "h_g3in4",
     "h_miles7d_k"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "The Penguins' starter has allowed about one extra goal every 3 starts, going by the chances he's faced over his last 30.",
    "share": 0.2229,
    "contribution": -0.11734,
    "kind": "driver",
    "features": [
     "h_gsax30",
     "a_gsax30",
     "a_goalie_known"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "The Stars have scored about 2.3% more than their chances earned \u2014 shooting and goaltending that hot usually cools.",
    "share": 0.0577,
    "contribution": -0.03035,
    "kind": "driver",
    "features": [
     "a_pdo25",
     "a_ga25",
     "a_xga25"
    ]
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "total",
  "pass_kind": "first",
  "graded_utc": "2026-10-09T16:45:19Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 104,
  "feature_version": 1,
  "model_p": 0.4615827365881877,
  "p_shipped": 0.4615827365881877,
  "model_mu": 6.8459496264310795,
  "market_p": 0.43908629441624364,
  "divergence": 0.022496442171944075,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 6.5,
  "anchor_book": "onexbet",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-10-09T16:00:19Z",
  "lineup_known": 0,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": null,
  "result": "lost",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "The Penguins have scored 4.2 goals a game over their last 25 and allowed 4.",
    "share": 0.6939,
    "contribution": 0.20597,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_gf25",
     "a_xga25",
     "h_xga25"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "situational",
    "phrase": "The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.",
    "share": 0.2883,
    "contribution": 0.08557,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_rest0",
     "h_g3in4",
     "a_miles7d_k"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "No goaltending record for tonight's starter for the Penguins \u2014 graded on league-typical assumptions.",
    "share": 0.0178,
    "contribution": 0.00528,
    "kind": "gap",
    "features": [
     "h_gsax_miss",
     "a_gsax_miss",
     "a_goalie_b2b"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "Penguins: Starter not yet confirmed \u2014 this read assumes the likely netminder and updates at morning skate.",
    "share": 0.0,
    "contribution": 0.0,
    "kind": "missing",
    "features": []
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "Stars: Starter not yet confirmed \u2014 this read assumes the likely netminder and updates at morning skate.",
    "share": 0.0,
    "contribution": 0.0,
    "kind": "missing",
    "features": []
   }
  ]
 },
 {
  "market": "total",
  "pass_kind": "final",
  "graded_utc": "2026-10-10T22:30:19Z",
  "rung": "l4",
  "fit_id": 104,
  "feature_version": 1,
  "model_p": 0.4879789068727091,
  "p_shipped": 0.4879789068727091,
  "model_mu": 6.645165310319687,
  "market_p": 0.48205128205128206,
  "divergence": 0.005927624821427058,
  "band": null,
  "anchor_line": 6.5,
  "anchor_book": "pinnacle",
  "anchor_fetched_utc": "2026-10-10T22:30:19Z",
  "lineup_known": 1,
  "ump_state": null,
  "weather_kind": null,
  "result": "lost",
  "factors": [
   {
    "family": "strength",
    "phrase": "The Penguins have scored 4.2 goals a game over their last 25 and allowed 4.",
    "share": 0.6833,
    "contribution": 0.2119,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_gf25",
     "a_xga25",
     "h_xga25"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "situational",
    "phrase": "The Penguins play the second of a back-to-back.",
    "share": 0.2759,
    "contribution": 0.08557,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_rest0",
     "h_g3in4",
     "a_miles7d_k"
    ]
   },
   {
    "family": "goalie",
    "phrase": "The Penguins' starter has allowed about one extra goal every 3 starts, going by the chances he's faced over his last 30.",
    "share": 0.0408,
    "contribution": 0.01265,
    "kind": "picture",
    "features": [
     "h_gsax30",
     "a_gsax30",
     "a_goalie_known"
    ]
   }
  ]
 }
]