SPOTTER.
How the published grades have done · 2026-07-29 – 2026-10-28
How to read this. One row per game and market — the final pre-pitch grade if there was one, otherwise the first. Every grade is frozen before first pitch and settled from the box score, and none is ever removed. Win % leaves pushes out; rows under 60 games are marked insufficient sample.
THE PICKS· every A, B and C grade, by market
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total3521791541953.8%
A grades583026253.6%insufficient sample
B grades1145653551.4%
C grades18093751255.4%
First-5-innings total4112031842452.5%
A grades482223348.9%insufficient sample
B grades1518261857.3%
C grades212991001349.7%
All graded picks7633823384353.1%
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
No lean — the market's right9554614355951.5%
Picks are every card where the model claimed an edge. No lean is every card where it agreed with the market — not a track record, since nothing there was ever a recommendation: its W and L are against the model's nominal side, bookkeeping, not a call.
BY MODEL· each model's own picks, newest first
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
v8 — the October rebuild (current) · Oct 7 – Oct 281585261.5%insufficient sample
Full-game total742166.7%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total843157.1%insufficient sample
v5 — the First-5 umpire fix · Sep 4 – Oct 73111531391952.4%
Full-game total16374781148.7%
First-5-innings total1487961856.4%
v2 — the August refit · Aug 8 – Sep 33511821521754.5%
Full-game total1609361660.4%
First-5-innings total19189911149.4%
v1 — the first model · Jul 29 – Aug 7863942548.1%
Full-game total22813138.1%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total643129451.7%
Each model's own picks, over the slates it was the one publishing — added together they are the season table above. A new model starts from zero, so read its sample size before its win rate. Shadow grades never appear on this page.
AGAINST THE CLOSE· the morning grade's line vs the same book's close
Did the line move our way? Each pick's line at the morning grade against the same book's close; a close from another book is not a move and is left unpriced. Beat % counts only the lines that moved, and avg move is runs toward the pick — the two markets are never added together.
SEGMENTNBEATFLATWORSEBEAT %AVG MOVE
Full-game total331432196938.4%-0.05 runs27 unpriced
First-5-innings total370562645052.8%+0.01 runs40 unpriced
MORE DETAIL· each model by band · if C were dropped · the close by band · over and under · starting pitchers · data gaps
EACH MODEL BY BAND· the model table, split by band
v8 — the October rebuild (current) · Oct 7 – Oct 28
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · B421166.7%insufficient sample
Full-game total · C321066.7%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · A1100100.0%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · B211050.0%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · C522150.0%insufficient sample
All graded picks1585261.5%insufficient sample
v5 — the First-5 umpire fix · Sep 4 – Oct 7
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · A281413151.9%insufficient sample
Full-game total · B502326146.9%insufficient sample
Full-game total · C853739948.7%
First-5-innings total · A1678146.7%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · B552724452.9%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · C774529360.8%
All graded picks3111531391952.4%
v2 — the August refit · Aug 8 – Sep 3
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · A22138161.9%insufficient sample
Full-game total · B462618259.1%insufficient sample
Full-game total · C925435360.7%
First-5-innings total · A251013243.5%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · B673826359.4%
First-5-innings total · C994152644.1%
All graded picks3511821521754.5%
v1 — the first model · Jul 29 – Aug 7
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · A835037.5%insufficient sample
Full-game total · B1458138.5%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · A642066.7%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · B271610161.5%insufficient sample
First-5-innings total · C311117339.3%insufficient sample
All graded picks863942548.1%
IF C WERE DROPPED· A and B only, per market
The open band question. The A and B rows added together, market by market — the record if C stopped publishing. Nothing is removed: C still publishes and keeps its own rows in the pick table.
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · AB combined — C set aside1728679752.1%
First-5-innings total · AB combined — C set aside199104841155.3%
All picks · AB combined — C set aside3711901631853.8%
AGAINST THE CLOSE — BY BAND· and the no-lean cards
By morning band, which can differ from the final band, so these rows do not add up to the pick tables and are not meant to. Measured from the final grade instead — written about an hour before first pitch, with the close captured 35 minutes before — 770 of 820 full-game total picks and 810 of 855 first-5-innings total picks closed at the very same line, so that anchor can only say the line stops moving once lineups are in. The morning grade is the one with hours to move.
SEGMENTNBEATFLATWORSEBEAT %AVG MOVE
Full-game total · A468271142.1%-0.04 runsinsufficient sample7 unpriced
Full-game total · B949632229.0%-0.11 runs14 unpriced
Full-game total · C191261293641.9%-0.03 runs6 unpriced
Full-game total · all graded picks331432196938.4%-0.05 runs27 unpriced
First-5-innings total · A576391233.3%-0.05 runsinsufficient sample8 unpriced
First-5-innings total · B10116741159.3%+0.03 runs13 unpriced
First-5-innings total · C212341512755.7%+0.02 runs19 unpriced
First-5-innings total · all graded picks370562645052.8%+0.01 runs40 unpriced
SEGMENTNBEATFLATWORSEBEAT %AVG MOVE
Full-game total · no lean437772758547.5%-0.01 runs65 unpriced
First-5-innings total · no lean407423145145.2%-0.01 runs43 unpriced
OVER VS UNDER — PICKS· every graded pick, by market
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · Over16591641058.7%
Full-game total · Under1878890949.4%
First-5-innings total · Over3151501452050.8%
First-5-innings total · Under965339457.6%
OVER VS UNDER — A AND B ONLY· C set aside
The picks the model rates highest — A and B — over and under: the block above minus its C grades.
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · Over743437347.9%
Full-game total · Under985242455.3%
First-5-innings total · Over1567869953.1%
First-5-innings total · Under432615263.4%insufficient sample
OVER VS UNDER — NO LEAN· not picks
Not picks. The model's nominal side on cards where it saw no edge — which way it leaned while making no call. It was never a recommendation.
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · Over2611231251349.6%
Full-game total · Under2461181141450.9%
First-5-innings total · Over2731361211652.9%
First-5-innings total · Under17584751652.8%
BY STARTING-PITCHING AGREEMENT· did the starters argue for the pick?
A watch, not a rule. On 2021-2024 history, picks the starting pitchers argued for won about 54% and picks they argued against 47-49%. The season-end read found no clear gap on this year's numbers, so it stays a watch. Nothing is filtered on it; a pick whose top five drivers leave out the starters is counted on its own.
SEGMENTNWLPUSHWIN %NOTES
Full-game total · starters argued for the pick203105881054.4%
Full-game total · starters argued against it422120151.2%insufficient sample
Full-game total · starters not among the five drivers1075346853.5%
First-5-innings total · starters argued for the pick3141511461750.8%
First-5-innings total · starters argued against it663429354.0%
First-5-innings total · starters not among the five drivers31189466.7%insufficient sample
Data gap · Jul 29 – Jul 31. Graded while the boxscore-context collector was dark — no fielding row had landed since 2026-07-12, so the 30-game fielding fold stayed frozen there. The 2026-08-01 re-parse refilled the fold; 2026-08-01 is the first slate graded against it. Nothing re-grades, so those grades are counted as written.
Data gap · Jul 29 – Aug 2. Graded while the IL collector was dark — no stint had been fetched since 2026-07-07, and a stint that was never fetched reads as no stint, so a starter just back from the injured list scored as healthy. It misread 11 of the 71 games on these dates — 12 starter-sides that should have carried an IL-return flag and did not. The 2026-08-03 repair refilled the stints; 2026-08-03 is the first slate graded against them. Nothing re-grades, so those grades are counted as written.
SERIES_UNDER — THE PERSONAL RULE· not a Spotter grade, and not a bet log
The owner's own rule. When a game finishes at least 4 runs under its closing total, take the under in the same series' next game. The model does not make it and no grade is written for it — the pipeline sends a nightly note and stops.
POPULATIONNUNDEROVERPUSHUNDER %ROI
Every trigger683530353.8%+4.6%
of which severe — 5+ runs under382015357.1%+10.6%
68 triggers since 2026-08-05 · 68 graded. Each row is the under at that game's closing total, one flat unit at the closing price. They are not bets. Nothing in the bet log is a SERIES_UNDER position. On 65 decided triggers the 95% range around 53.8% runs 42–65% — too wide to tell a coin flip from the screened edge, which took 1,261 triggers to show 54.61% under and +5.63% ROI against a 52.38% break-even. Tracking the screen so far is not evidence the rule works.
What this counts: every grade Spotter wrote, settled against the box score — winners and losers in the same table, and no row ever removed. Model fit 2021–2026, leave-one-season-out; F5 grades ride a shorter history (2023–2026). No grade is ever re-graded; only its result is filled in after the game. · Research, not betting advice. 21+. Problem? 1-800-GAMBLER.